Use Cases for eSignatures
In India, eSignatures that comply with the Information Technology Act, 2000 — such as Aadhaar eSign or click-to-sign solutions — are legally valid for most routine business and operational documentation. Common and legally accepted use cases include:
- Business Agreements NDAs, vendor agreements, employment contracts, service agreements, partnership MoUs.
- Human Resources Offer letters, onboarding forms, leave approvals, appraisal records, policy acknowledgments.
- Procurement & Sales Purchase orders, sales contracts, customer onboarding forms, renewal documents.
- Banking & Financial Services Account opening forms (especially when Aadhaar eSign is used), loan applications, digital consent for services.
- Government & Citizen Services Forms submitted via e-governance portals using Aadhaar eSign (e.g., DigiLocker, NSDL, GSTN).
- Insurance & Telecom Policy issuance, claim forms, onboarding and consent forms.
As long as the eSignature method complies with Indian standards (e.g., Aadhaar eSign or those with proper audit trails), these use cases are both legally valid and enforceable.
Use Cases for Qualified Signatures (Digital Signatures/DSC)
In the Indian context, Qualified Signatures refer to Digital Signatures issued by licensed Certifying Authorities (CAs) under the IT Act. These are mandatory or strongly preferred in regulated, high-value, or sensitive environments. Key use cases include:
- Statutory & Regulatory Filings
- MCA filings (ROC forms, incorporation, director KYC).
- Income Tax filings (mandatory for companies and LLPs).
- GST return submissions for certain taxpayers.
- Government Procurement & Bidding
- E-tender submissions and bid documents.
- Compliance reports, certifications, and license applications.
- Financial Documents
- Signing audited financial statements.
- Board resolutions, loan documentation, investor agreements.
- Financial Documents
- Signing audited financial statements.
- Board resolutions, loan documentation, investor agreements.
- Legal & Compliance Documents
- Notices under Company Law.
- Declarations or affidavits required by regulatory authorities.
- Enterprise-Grade Workflows
- High-security internal systems (e.g., BFSI, pharma, manufacturing sectors).
These signatures carry presumptions of validity under Sections 85A & 85B of the Indian Evidence Act and offer strong legal defensibility.
Use Cases Not Appropriate for Electronic Signatures in India
Indian law excludes certain document types from being signed electronically, as listed in the First Schedule of the IT Act, 2000. In such cases, physical (wet ink) signatures or specific forms like notarized or registered documents are required. These include:
- Wills & Testamentary DocumentsE.g., last will and testament, codicils.
- Trust DeedsCreation or amendment of trusts.
- Powers of AttorneyEspecially those involving immovable property transactions.
- Real Estate InstrumentsSale deeds, lease agreements, gift deeds, or any document that must be registered under the Registration Act, 1908.
- Negotiable InstrumentsPromissory notes, bills of exchange (except cheques in some digital contexts).
- Court Documents & AffidavitsDocuments requiring attestation or notarization for court submissions.
For these types of documents, electronic signatures — even qualified ones — are not legally sufficient and may be rejected by courts or authorities.
List of Local Trust Service Providers
Institute | Regulatory Body/CA/DSC Providers | Supported by emSigner | Website |
---|---|---|---|
Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology - Controller of Certifying Authorities | Controller of Certification Authorities | yes | http://www.cca.gov.in/cca/ |
eMudhra | CA | yes | http://www.e-mudhra.com/ |
NSDL | CA | yes | https://www.nsdl.co.in/ |
Capricorn | CA | yes | https://www.certificate.digital/ |
CDAC | CA | yes | https://esign.cdac.in/ |
(n) Code Solutions | CA | yes | http://www.ncodesolutions.com/ |
National Informatics Centre | CA | yes | https://www.nic.in/ |
IDRBT | CA | yes | http://idrbtca.org.in/ |
Safescrypt | CA | yes | https://www.sifytechnologies.com/us/ |
General Definitions
Simple Electronic Signature (SES)
A Simple Electronic Signature (SES) refers to any electronic data that is logically associated with other electronic data and used by a person to sign. This can include:
- Typing a name at the end of an email,
- Clicking an “I accept” button,
- Pasting a scanned image of a signature, or
- Using a stylus or finger to draw a signature on a touchscreen.
While SES can indicate intent to sign, it lacks advanced identity verification, integrity protection, or security features, making it the least secure type of electronic signature. It is legally valid in many jurisdictions but may not carry strong evidentiary weight without additional context or proof.
Advanced Electronic Signature (AES)
An Advanced Electronic Signature (AES) is a more secure form of electronic signature that must meet the following criteria:
- it is uniquely linked to the signatory
- it is capable of identifying the signatory
- it is created using means that are under the sole control of the signatory, and
- it is linked to the signed data in such a way that any subsequent change in the data is detectable.
AES provides enhanced legal reliability compared to SES and is often supported by multi-factor authentication, encryption, and audit trails.
Qualified Electronic Signature (QES)
A Qualified Electronic Signature (QES) is a type of Advanced Electronic Signature that additionally:
- is created using a qualified signature creation device (such as a secure token or smart card); and
- is backed by a qualified digital certificate issued by a recognized or accredited trust service provider.
QES provides the highest level of trust and legal assurance, and in many jurisdictions (like the EU under eIDAS, India IT Act, etc), it holds the same legal status as a handwritten signature.
Digital Signature
A Digital Signature is a specific technological implementation of an electronic signature that uses asymmetric cryptography. It allows a verifier to:
- confirm that the signature was created using the private key corresponding to the signer’s public key; and
- ensure that the signed message or document has not been altered after signing.
Digital signatures are the underlying cryptographic mechanism used in both AES and QES. They offer strong security guarantees such as authenticity, integrity, and non-repudiation and are often implemented through Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) systems.
External Resources
DISCLAIMER
This information is intended to help you understand the legal framework of electronic signatures. However, eMudhra cannot provide legal advice. The law of electronic signatures is constantly evolving. This guide is not intended as a legal advice and should not serve as a substitute for professional legal advice. You should consult an attorney regarding any specific legal concerns. eMudhra, and all associates including agents, officers, employees or affiliates, are not liable for any direct, indirect, incidental, special, exemplary or consequential damages.